Connecting the BMP280 barometric sensor to the Puck, lots of ERROR messages..

Does your module have pullup resistors on it? I2C needs them to work.

However, you could try software I2C:

var i2c = new I2C();
i2c.setup({scl:D2,sda:D1});
var bme = require("BMP280").connect(i2c);
console.log(bme.getData());

Software I2C can use the chip's internal pullups, so might be able to work without external ones.